「如果34人中有33人不及格,問題不在家裡」:一位一年級教師含淚解釋教學有多麼「令人筋疲力盡」,並引發辯論:是家庭的錯還是教師的錯?

Por Alexander
15 October, 2026

34名六、七歲的學生,一位教師,只有一人及格。

Carol Fernandez 教一年級,並錄製了一段 TikTok 影片,片中她在鏡頭前情緒崩潰。

她說,在她的34名學生中,只有一名女生通過了高頻詞彙評量。「我累壞了」,她說。

她已經連續忙了兩個月,並說自己的身體正告訴她該放慢腳步,但她必須把自己的感受放一邊,專心照顧學生。有件事讓她感到害怕:她把那個詞寫在黑板上,幾名學生卻抄錯了。她不禁懷疑是不是自己的錯。

在她看來,問題的一部分出在家裡,不過那只是她的看法。許多教師回覆說,他們也遇到了同樣的情況。

其他使用者認為,班上學生這麼多,沒有人能取得更好的成果。還有人主張,如果幾乎沒有人及格,責任就不能歸咎於家庭。

問題出在教室、家庭,還是體制? 🤔

@.carolgiselle

I went back and forth about sharing this video, but today was honestly one of the hardest days of the school year so far. I love being a teacher. I truly believe this is my calling, and I wouldn’t share the parts of my classroom that I do if I didn’t care so deeply about my students and education. But I also think we need to be honest about how hard this job can be. It’s exhausting. It’s heartbreaking to see how many students are struggling with reading and how much support they need. Sometimes you leave school thinking about all the things you wish you could do differently, all the students you wish you could reach a little more, and everything you’re carrying into the next day. I share so much of my classroom because I want other teachers to feel less alone, and I want people to understand what teaching really looks like. Not just the cute classroom setups, the activities, and the good days, but the days that remind you just how much this job asks of you. I love my students. I love what I do. And I can be grateful for this calling while also admitting that some days are really, really hard. If you’re a teacher having one of those days, I hope you know you’re not alone. ❤️ #TeacherTok #TeachersOfTikTok #ElementaryTeacher #Teaching #Literacy

♬ original sound – .carolgiselle

Puede interesarte